Search icone
Search and publish your papers

Judicial activism in Canada

Or download with : a doc exchange

About the author

Level
General public

About the document

Published date
Language
documents in English
Format
Word
Type
presentations
Pages
5 pages
Level
General public
Accessed
1 times
Validated by
Committee Oboolo.com
0 Comment
Rate this document
  1. Introduction.
  2. Canadian courts: Grand decisions since the adoption of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms in 1982.
  3. The behaviour of the Canadian courts.
  4. The question of legitimacy in judicial activism.
  5. Virulent criticisms and judicial activism.
  6. Conclusion.
  7. Bibliogaphy.

In 1982, Canada has known a very significant shift with the adoption of the Charter of Right of Freedom. Before this date, Canada only had a Bill of Rights (1960's) which was a statute and did not allow the courts to restrict the action of the Parliament. But the 1982 Charter of Rights and Freedom has led to a rights revolution and Canada has become a "jurisdocracy" (expression of Hirschl). Courts now have the opportunity to interpret the Constitution and to strike down some laws, if they consider that these laws do not respect people's rights. This could be seen as a progress but in fact, this has triggered off a lot of criticisms. As a matter of fact, Canadian courts do not hesitate to use their power a lot and this activism is sometimes considered as a threat. No one can deny that very important issues such as gay rights or euthanasia are now in the hands of unelected judges. Is this really their role? Some argue that courts in Canada are too activist and are usurping the powers of elected legislatures. So we can wonder, to what extent court activism is a threat to Canadian democracy?

[...] For example, the Supreme Court of Canada really have a mandate to impose two tiered medicare on the people of Canada under Section Some writers have a very extreme opinion on the subject; Ian Hunter argues that ?Canada's Charter of Rights has forever altered the system of government in Canada: it has led to judicial activism and an emasculated Parliament, and has set Canada on the road to totalitarianism?[26]. Edward Mac Bride describes this phenomenon as the consequence of a ?rampant individualism that has gone from rights-consciousness to rights- obsession?[27]. [...]


[...] There are several examples of sensible courts decisions; ?time and again over the past 20 years, unelected judges on this Court have issued guidelines on legislative policy to the democratically elected representatives of the people of Canada in what is supposed to be the legislative branch of government?[2]. One of the big fields of debate concerns gay rights. In the Vriend case, the court has granted spousal benefits to same sex couples. Obviously, court read a right into two different enactments directly contrary to the wishes of the legislatures that passed them?[3]. [...]


[...] Rory Leishman, Against Judicial Activism : the Decline of Freedom and Democracy in Canada. Mac Gill-Queen's University Press Page 3. Edward Mac Bride Chief Justice shocks Canada, the role of opinion polls Judicial Activism: a threat to democracy and religion, Alphonse de Valk Page 13. Rory Leishman, Against Judicial Activism : the Decline of Freedom and Democracy in Canada. Mac Gill-Queen's University Press Page 4. Rory Leishman, Against Judicial Activism : the Decline of Freedom and Democracy in Canada. Mac Gill-Queen's University Press Page 6. [...]

Similar documents you may be interested in reading.

An analysis of why Canada's regulation of competition is weaker than in the United States

 Politics & international   |  Political science   |  Term papers   |  05/28/2009   |   .doc   |   9 pages

Country Analysis - Canada (2007)

 Economics & finance   |  Economics   |  Market study   |  09/29/2010   |   .pdf   |   36 pages

Top sold for political science

Anarchy and the limits of cooperation: a realist critique of the liberal institutionalism - J.M....

 Politics & international   |  Political science   |  Case study   |  02/27/2013   |   .doc   |   2 pages

A critical review of Downs, A. (1957) 'An Economic Theory of Political Action in a Democracy',...

 Politics & international   |  Political science   |  Case study   |  07/23/2013   |   .doc   |   3 pages