Search icone
Search and publish your papers

Women representation in politics: A comparative approach between France and the Nordic countries

Or download with : a doc exchange

About the author

 
Level
Advanced

About the document

Published date
Language
documents in English
Format
Word
Type
thesis
Pages
32 pages
Level
Advanced
Accessed
1 times
Validated by
Committee Oboolo.com
0 Comment
Rate this document
  1. Historical and empirical data illustrating the gap in women mobilisation
    1. Rokkan's model on mobilisation of women in parliamentary politics
    2. The main and illustrative data of women political representation in France and in the Nordic countries
    3. The insufficiency of economic arguments for our study
  2. Beyond economic explanations: alternative factors to grasp the gap
    1. General cultural barriers to women empowerment
    2. The specific religious factor in women mobilisation
    3. An alternative and complementary explanation: the prevalence of institutional obstacles
  3. The increasing importance of affirmative actions: the nordic tolerance vs. French resistance to institutional promotion of women representation
    1. The implementation of quotas: general
    2. The Nordic countries: an incremental model
    3. The original French parity
  4. Conclusion
  5. List of literature
  6. Annexes

Nowadays women are increasingly accessing to high political positions in State office. Indeed, three women recently reached the status of Head of State in different countries: Michelle Bachelet in Chile, Ellen Johnson-Sirlead in Liberia, and Tarja Halonen in Finland. Moreover, women play more crucial roles on the political scene than before, as it is the case in France with the ambitious Ségolène Royal who is currently working very hard to become a possible presidential candidate and to overcome male scoffing. Nonetheless, progress in the inclusion of women's voices in politics and government has proved difficult. Despite some well-known world leaders, such as Margaret Thatcher, Gro Harlem Bruntland and Golda Meir, only thirty-nine countries have ever elected a woman president or Prime Minister. According to the UN report, today women compose less than one-tenth of the world's cabinet ministers (Inglehart and Norris, 2003).
Indeed, the gender variable is often used in political studies to explain political phenomena, in confronting men and women behaviours, even if other elements (like age, profession, social status ?) are available to grasp striking individual differences towards politics. However, it is important to introduce qualifications concerning the relevance of a gender approach because women do not always constitute a homogeneous group. But this does not jeopardize this study since it has been proven that political conducts exist proper to female.
When studying women in politics, several relevant approaches can be envisaged. For instance, gender gaps in voting behaviours had been for a long time put forward as women appeared to become more inclined than men to vote in the left of the political field since the 1980s (Oskarson, 1995) despite their traditional and apparently well-established conservatism. Comparing gender differences in ideology, public opinion and electoral preferences can be considered as being the most common approach to elaborate the meaning of the term ?gender gap'.
Nevertheless, concerning gender and politics, two conceptions have been developed namely the pessimistic and the optimistic perspectives. The first one aimed at stressing permanent predominance of males and consequently the continuous female exclusion. In this view, even the increasing proportion of women in political bodies is justified by the decline in the power and significance of political institutions. Moreover, the fact that women have integrated the so-called ?soft side' of politics (meaning the low status fields) restricts the relevance of female increasing empowerment (Bergqvist, 1999). The second approach asserts a sure degree of autonomy of politics and political institutions envisaging the possibility of positive changes in gender political positions because of the great importance given to actors. Today, the optimistic view takes prevalence in most studies.
For our part, we found germane to rely on Rokkan's model, developed in the 1970s, which resorts to four institutional thresholds that must be passed or overcome by the mobilising women group to achieve political power in parliamentary system (Raaum, 2004). In this model, each threshold constitutes an institutional obstacle while each phase in between can be considered as mobilisation periods.
Our study will focus on a comparative approach of female representation in politics at the national level of each country, i.e. France and four Nordic countries (Sweden, Denmark, Norway and Finland). We put aside the Icelandic case since its gender profile differs from the situation in the four other Nordic countries. Indeed, its level of female political representation is relatively low (mainly because of its electoral system) and the social citizenship of Icelandic women has not been as broad as in the rest of the Nordic countries (Borchorst, Christensen, Raaum, 1999). Icelandic society has been regarded as a ?strong male-breadwinner model' (Raaum, 2004). Thus, from now on, the expression ?Nordic countries' encompasses only these major four countries. Besides, France seems to be an appropriate case on that subject as equality between men and women in politics has been a controversial and thorny question in our native country for decades.
Finally, let us clarify a few details on the Nordic case. In comparative studies, many authors lay the emphasis on the homogeneity of the Nordic countries in designating them as a ?case apart' in the matter of female representation (Karvonen, Selle, 1995). As tending to be at the top of the list concerning women representation in politics, Denmark, Norway, Sweden and Finland are often considered by the optimists as well as by the pessimists as a special model because of its unique character and its attempt to build a brighter future for women. However, we cannot deny that even though the Nordic countries share many common features, it must be admitted that several differences remain on the subject notably concerning the women integration strategies elaborated in each country. As it is highlighting by Christensen, the Nordic countries have chosen to develop various strategies in order to integrate women especially in the political field. For instance, Finland and Sweden have opted for a ?classic strategy' by relying upon a tradition of women' s sections in the political parties but also on the penetration of new women mobilisation in the parties. On the other hand, Norway and Denmark have done differently. Indeed, Norway has followed a ?modern strategy'; for instance, through the strengthening of the parties by the new mobilisation women or by their integration by means of quotas. Denmark, for its part, did not develop any integration strategy as the mobilisation of women used channels other than political parties since women for example lack sections within the parties (Christensen, 1999). Nonetheless, the central statistics underline that the Nordic countries offer a specific model of women representation in politics. In fact, in the early 1990s, there were 30 percent of women in Nordic parliaments whereas the world average, even today, hardly reaches about 16 percent. In addition, what is striking is that such a pattern is met not only concerning parliaments but also with regards to the executive branch of governments and to cabinet members. Agreeing with this rationale, we will compare the performance of the Nordic model to the French situation with respect to the four thresholds of women mobilisation.
In fact, theories about women and political power set a discrepancy between, on the one hand, women's lack of authority and, on the other hand, the political practice indicating their increasing degree of mobilisation as decision-makers in public policies. The political mobilisation of Nordic women constitutes a striking contrast to the so-called ?powerlessness model' to which France in our study may relatively belong (Raaum, 1995).
Luckily, thanks to reports provided by national French and Nordic authorities, numerous data on our subject are available that will constitute the point of departure of our study. These figures shed light on the existing gap of women representation in politics between France and the Nordic countries. Hence, we can wonder how these countries, close in many aspects such as economic development, may be so divergent in the field of our study as France is much far from realizing women expectations.
On this subject, many scholars put forward a common theory of the 1960s and early 1970s which argued that economic growth was the most effective strategy and incentive for the improvements of women status (Inglehart, Norris, 2003). These authors rely upon other factors to explain ?the rising tide of gender equality' such as the role of state or the cultural variable. To our point of view, we must follow this rationale in evoking other factors for women empowerment as we are comparing countries which are close economically speaking.
Our cross-national study will concentrate first on empirical and historical data illustrating the gap in women political presence between France and the Nordic countries (1). Then, we will try to sort out possible explanations for these differences that go beyond economic factors (2). Finally, it appears relevant to introduce a perspective on our subject by tackling the question of measures that aim at promoting women political representation (3).

[...] Our cross-national study will concentrate first on empirical and historical data illustrating the gap in women political presence between France and the Nordic countries Then, we will try to sort out possible explanations for these differences that go beyond economic factors Finally, it appears relevant to introduce a perspective on our subject by tackling the question of measures that aim at promoting women political representation PART HISTORICAL AND EMPIRICAL DATA ILLUSTRATING THE GAP IN WOMEN MOBILISATION According to us, Rokkan's model establishes an interesting and germane point of departure to study women's mobilisation in politics. [...]


[...] The main and illustrative data of women political representation in France and in the Nordic countries Following the previous model, we will enunciate data concerning the four thresholds. First of all, the phase of legitimisation in the Nordic countries mainly dealt with feminist organizations and with the establishment of suffrage organizations (Nagel, 1995) starting in 1870s. The first Danish feminist organization was created in 1871 and the first women's suffrage association in 1889. For the three other countries taken in our subject, feminist organizations appeared in 1884. [...]


[...] Gender and Politics in the Nordic countries, Oslo: Scandinavian University Press, p 276- Knut Heidar ?Parties and party systems' in Knut Heidar (2004): Nordic Politics: Comparative perspectives, Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, p40- Hanna Marthe Narud ?Parliamentary nominations and political representation-Group representation or party mandates?' in Knut Heidar (2004): Nordic Politics: Comparative perspectives, Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, p108- Nina C. Raaum presence of women in parliamentary politics' in Knut Heidar (2004): Nordic Politics: Comparative perspectives, Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, p142- Knut Heidar ?Comparative perspectives on the Northern countries' in Knut Heidar (2004): Nordic Politics: Comparative perspectives, Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, p262- Christensen, Ann-Dorte (1997), De politisk-kulturelle betydninger af kon, in Ann-Dorte Christensen, Ann-Birthe Ravn and Iris Rittenhofer Det konnede samfund; Aalborg: Aalborg Universitetsforlag Christensen, Ann-Dorte ans Nina C.Raaum (1999), Models of political mobilisation, in Christina Berqvist et al. [...]

Similar documents you may be interested in reading.

Women's political representation in Sweden and in France. Comparative study

 Social studies   |  Sociology   |  Presentation   |  09/29/2010   |   .doc   |   10 pages

Women representation in politics: A comparative approach between France and the Nordic countries

 Politics & international   |  Political science   |  Thesis   |  09/29/2010   |   .doc   |   32 pages

Top sold for political science

Anarchy and the limits of cooperation: a realist critique of the liberal institutionalism - J.M....

 Politics & international   |  Political science   |  Case study   |  02/27/2013   |   .doc   |   2 pages

Discussion about the differences between nationalism and national identity

 Politics & international   |  Political science   |  Presentation   |  09/29/2010   |   .doc   |   8 pages