Search icone
Search and publish your papers

Essay on human rights

About the author

General public

About the document

Published date
documents in English
term papers
10 pages
General public
0 times
Validated by
  1. Introduction
  2. The court's ruling in the Gafgen case
    1. Procedure and reasoning of the ECHR
    2. Why the Strasbourg Court found fault in the way the German courts dealt with the case?
  3. Are torture and inhuman always absolutely prohibited
    1. The absolute prohibition of torture and the consequent exclusionary rule
    2. The inaction involved in the Gäfgen judgment about the exclusionary rule for real evidence is proof of a flaw in the absolute prohibition of torture
  4. When can torture be justified, if at all?
    1. Morally, the necessity doctrine justifies torture
    2. Legally, the absolute prohibition of torture is still relevant today, even in extreme circumstances
  5. Conclusion

"Imagine that you are creating a fabric of human destiny with the object of making men happy in the end [], but that it was essential and inevitable to torture to death only one tiny creature [], would you consent to be the architect on those conditions?". There, Fyodor Dostoevsky asked the controversial question: can torture be ever justified? This issue was examined during the ?long-awaited judgment? of the Gäfgen case , where, on the 27 September 2002, the applicant lured Jakob, a 11 year old boy, into his flat in Frankfurt am Main and killed him by suffocation. On the same day he asked his parents for a ransom of €1 million, while he hid the corpse under a ?jetty? . Three days after, while collecting the ransom, he was arrested by the police, after having been informed of the charges against him and his rights as a defendant. The Deputy Chief of the Frankfurt police, Daschner, ordered E to threaten the applicant and if necessary to inflict actual pain, in order to discover the child's whereabouts. E threatened the applicant with possible ?subjection to considerable pain at the hands of a person specially trained for such purposes? . The applicant also claimed that E threatened him to be locked in a cell with two other people who would sexually abuse him. Further in the ill-treatment, the police officer hit Gäfgen several times. Finally, the applicant revealed the whereabouts of the child ten minutes later. At that time, the police was firmly convinced that Jakob was still alive, and therefore they conducted the interrogation with the goal to save the child's life. Gäfgen was then driven to the place he indicated to show the exact location of the corpse. Going back to the police station, the applicant confessed the kidnapping and the murder of the child. On January 2003, the prosecutor opened investigation proceedings.

In that case, the Courts ? German courts, but also the ECHR ? had to consider whether or not in extreme circumstances such as the kidnapping of a child, torture can be justified to save a life.

A worldwide opinion poll testing this argument showed that 59% of the world's population consider that torture cannot be inflicted, even in extreme circumstances where the life of a person ? or a group of person ? is at stake . The question as to who is right and who is wrong does not have any static answer. Can torture be ever justified? Every response can be argued. However, if one considers that ?yes? is the right one, then, what are the circumstances which would justify the use of torture?

After having examined the reasoning of the ECHR in the Gäfgen case (i), one should consider the absolute character of the prohibition of torture through the decision of the Strasbourg Court (ii). Finally, one should debate the circumstances in which torture can be justified, if at all (iii).

Top sold for social sciences

The Role of Sexuality and Race in This Earth of Mankind

 Politics & international   |  Social sciences   |  Term papers   |  05/03/2007   |   .doc   |   3 pages

SWOT analysis on National Society of the Prevention Cruelty to Children's Online Program

 Politics & international   |  Social sciences   |  Term papers   |  05/30/2009   |   .doc   |   4 pages

Recent documents in social sciences category

Applying Sociological Theories on my Personal Life: Sex and Gender

 Politics & international   |  Social sciences   |  Presentation   |  03/17/2020   |   .doc   |   4 pages

How the French health system was built ? What are the mechanisms?

 Politics & international   |  Social sciences   |  Presentation   |  08/30/2019   |   .doc   |   3 pages