In this article, the author, Rebecca Filliponi explains the similarities and differences in community work and social work, and how they affect the community by examining how they both integrate by using research tools, case studies and interviews. The author suggests that by doing this, a greater understanding is achieved in knowing the outcome of intervention by community work and social work with the community.
Wayne, Gregory Colomb and Joseph Williams suggest that the introduction should highlight the problem and the solutions proposed by the author. Rebecca Filliponi has done that by introducing the community work and social work having several similarities and differences as a problem, and using two research tools, four case studies, and interviews to find solutions. Rebecca is to be commended for using her sense of judgment by preserving the confidentiality of the persons in the interview by giving them false names, Julie and John to ensure they provide accurate information without the fear of exposing themselves (Booth, Gregory & Joseph, 1995)
On the issue of integration of social work and community development in practice, the author has identified issues that hinder the effective occurrence of being supported by organizations, workers and professional bodies. Rebecca makes us understand these four issues by tackling them one after the other. These issues discussed by the author include the difference in values and approaches, community development workers and social workers do not understand the role of each other's profession, a difference in importance placed on professional qualifications and the two professions do not want to be associated with each other (Filliponi, n. d).
[...] Critical critique of a paper on community development in social work Abstract Rebecca Filliponi suggests that there are differences and similarities between community work and social work. Although there are stark differences materializing in some cases, there are also ways to view their similarities and how they integrate together to solve problems in the community. The author shows the differences and similarities that are occurring by using interviews, two research tools and four case studies. Keywords: community, social, integrates, similarities, differences. [...]
[...] Coulton, C. (2005). Place of Community in Social Work Practice Research: Conceptual and Methodological developments' Social Work Research 73-87 Filliponi, R. (n. d). Integrating social work and community development? An analysis of their similarities and differences and the effect on practice. South Africa: Monash University Caulfield Campus Mendes, P. (2003). Community Development and Social Work: Are they compatible? [...]
[...] The similarities are shown by the author where community development workers and social workers work in consultation with each other and not together because social workers work with families while development workers mingle with families in addition to other clients. On the third issue, the author continues to highlight the difference between social workers and community development workers. Here, professional qualification for university is seen as significant to social workers to attain a position and this is why Julie has a Bachelor of Social and Welfare and Work. Contrary to this, community development workers just require any qualification to attain the title community development worker and this has been shown where John has a Bachelor of Arts. [...]
[...] To conclude, the author has been able to show us the differences and similarities (Mendes, 2006) between social workers and community development workers. It seems that social workers are more into professionalism while community development workers are more into sharing skills; however social workers and community development workers consult each other on as per needed basis. Although social workers and community development workers are hindered from working together, education would be a better remedy to allow the two to integrate and work together for the purpose of benefiting the client. [...]
APA Style referenceFor your bibliography
Online readingwith our online reader
Content validatedby our reading committee